a great oak serving as a known landmark, the one tree by which a boundary was described
This is the ordinary Hebrew word for an oak, and in the one place it works as a common noun it names a single tree that everybody in the area could find. The surveyor listing the northern tribe of Naphtali's border gives directions by it: the line runs from Heleph, from the oak at Zaanannim, and on past Adami Nekeb and Jabneel. A tree that size did the job a bridge or a water tower does for us. The same tree shows up again in Judges 4:11, where Heber the Kenite pitches his tent beside it shortly before Jael kills Sisera.
Which Hebrew word actually stands here is genuinely uncertain, and it is worth knowing why English Bibles look so different at this verse. Hebrew had a small cluster of words for these big trees, and in a text written without vowel marks two of them are identical on the page: the plain word for an oak (אַלּוֹן) and the word reserved for a great tree known by name (אֵלוֹן). Printed editions and lexicons split over which one Joshua 19:33 has. Older English versions took a third route and read the two words as a place name, "Allon to Zaanannim", as though a town were meant, and that is how this verse came to be filed under the same number as the man named Allon.
Nothing in the verse itself says anything religious about the tree. Elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible a tree known by name is very often a holy place as well, and the Kenites who camped at this one were outsiders with their own traditions, so scholars have wondered whether the spot had that kind of standing. The verse gives no hint either way. It is drawing a line on a map, and the tree is the fixed point it uses.
How the word at Joshua 19:33 should be read. The consonants cannot decide it: pointed one way the text has the ordinary noun for an oak, which older English versions took as the place name Allon in Zaanannim, and pointed the other way it has the noun used of a great tree known by name, the same tree beside which Heber the Kenite camps at Judges 4:11. The critical apparatus records both readings, which is why reference works differ over whether this verse belongs with the arboreal noun or with the homographic personal name.
- majorityThe noun for a great named tree, so the verse names the same landmark tree as Judges 4:11 and the phrase means the great tree, or oak, at Zaanannim; BDB, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford, 1906), 18, s.v., following the vocalizers Norzi, Baer and Dillmann; Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia and Biblia Hebraica Quinta, apparatus at Joshua 19:33
- minorityThe ordinary noun for an oak as the printed vowels give it, which older English versions rendered as a place name, Allon in Zaanannim; Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft, 1977), text at Joshua 19:33