The onomastic literature is unanimous that the name derives from the arboreal noun and not from the divine element El. Noth, Die israelitischen Personennamen (BWANT 46, 1928), classes Elon among plant names and keeps it apart from theophoric formations; Fowler, Theophoric Personal Names in Ancient Hebrew (JSOTSup 49, 1988), omits it from her theophoric corpus; Zadok assigns it to the well attested West Semitic class of names formed from flora, comparable to Tamar and Rimmon. BDB 18 and HALOT 1:54 treat the underlying noun as a great tree marking a shrine or landmark, and the differences in pointing among the related arboreal nouns are Masoretic rather than consonantal, which is why the name, the tree words, and the place name Aijalon are graphically indistinguishable in an unvocalized text. On Elon the Hittite (Gen 26:34; 36:2), Sarna, Wenham, and Hamilton note that the ordinary Semitic name is part of the evidence that the Hittites of the Genesis narratives are a Canaanite group rather than the Anatolian Hatti; the divergence between Basemath (26:34) and Adah (36:2) as the daughter's name belongs to the wider source-critical discussion of Esau's wives, not to the identification of the father. For the judge (Judg 12:11 to 12), Brettler, Thompson, and Boling raise the possibility that the minor judges were originally eponymous clan names later personified, noting that the Vaticanus tradition of LXX Judges collapses the personal name and the toponym Aijalon into one form; Moskowitz argues instead for a historical Zebulunite claim on a formerly Danite Aijalon. For the Danite town of Josh 19:43, Cogan and Sweeney identify Elon-beth-hanan of 1 Kgs 4:9 with it; the Danite allotment lists both Aijalon (v. 42) and Elon (v. 43), separated only by pointing.