to pay back in full: to give a person exactly what their deeds or debts have earned, whether restitution, reward, or punishment
This is the word's most common use by far, and the courtroom is where it lives. When an ox gores a neighbor's animal, when a borrowed tool is broken, when a thief is caught, the wrong has left a hole in the community, and this verb names the act that fills it: pay back, in full, until the injured party is whole again. Israel's law shares this vocabulary with its neighbors, whose own legal records use the same word for compensation in almost identical cases.
From the courtroom the word spreads outward. God pays people back what their lives have earned, and the striking thing is that one verb carries both directions. Blessing to the faithful and disaster to the wicked are named with the same word, because in each case a person is simply handed the full measure of what they did. The verse, not the word, tells you whether the payback is a gift or a sentence.
Because the idea is settling an account rather than punishing, the word can turn generous. God promises to pay back Israel for the years the locusts ate, and to give comfort back to those who mourn, using the same verb that elsewhere threatens Babylon.
Nuances
Whether Proverbs 11:31 originally read the Masoretic "the righteous is requited on earth" (Pual יְשֻׁלָּם) or the reading behind the Septuagint, quoted at 1 Peter 4:18, "the righteous is scarcely saved".
- majorityThe Masoretic reading is original: the righteous is requited on earth, and how much more the wicked and the sinner.; B. K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 1-15, NICOT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004)
- minorityThe Greek tradition preserves an ancient alternative reading, which the New Testament quotation at 1 Peter 4:18 attests.; Septuagint, Proverbs 11:31 (quoted at 1 Peter 4:18)