agitation: shaking, churning commotion that will not settle, whether in a rumbling sky, a quivering body, an unquiet life, or a burst of anger
This word names motion that refuses to settle. The verb behind it (רָגַז) is used of ground heaving in an earthquake and of whole nations shuddering at the news of an advancing army, and the noun keeps that picture: it is the shaking itself, not the feeling behind the shaking. Because the image is so physical, it can be applied to almost anything that has been worked up.
That is why one short noun covers a range English has to break into pieces:
- the rumble of thunder rolling out of a storm cloud
- a war-horse quivering as it swallows the ground toward a battle
- a life so churned up that ease, quiet and rest are all out of reach
- and, at the far edge, anger itself
Anger is real here, but it sits at the outer edge rather than the center. Hebrew's usual anger words picture burning heat (חֵמָה) or flaring nostrils (אַף); this one pictures shaking, so where it does mean anger it means anger as visible agitation. Only one verse, Habakkuk 3:2, clearly asks in Hebrew to be read that way. Much of the pull toward anger comes from Aramaic, where the same root (רְגַז) had become the everyday word for rage by the time of Daniel and Ezra, and later readers heard the Hebrew noun through that.
Job uses the noun more than anyone else, always for the state he cannot escape. He says he is not at ease, not quiet, not at rest, and then that this has come instead. Read as unrest, the line is the heart of his complaint. Read as anger, it turns him into an angry man, which is not what he is claiming.
Nuances
Whether the noun at Job 3:17 names the turmoil the wicked are released from in death or the raging they cease to inflict.
- majorityTurmoil or agitation: the restless striving of life that stops in the grave, matching the rest given to the weary in the second half of the verse. Jerome already read commotion here, and Hernandez presses the reading so far as to render the paired subject as the restless rather than the wicked.; David J. A. Clines, Job 1-20 (Word Biblical Commentary 17, 1989), on 3:17; Vulgate, Job 3:17 (a tumultu); Dominick S. Hernandez, essay on Job 3:17 in the Edward L. Greenstein Festschrift (SBL Press, 2021)
- minorityRaging or wrath: the wicked cease from their rage. The Old Greek renders the noun with words for fury and wrath, and BDB itself files this verse under raging.; Septuagint (Old Greek), Job 3:17 (thymon orges); BDB, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament, s.v. רֹגֶז