StrongerBible

ma'aneh

מַעֲנֶה

HebrewH4617answer, reply, ...

Appears 7 times · tap a cell to see the verses

Job 32:3Job 32:5Pro 15:1Pro 15:23Pro 16:1Pro 16:4Mic 3:7
Root family
Word studymah-uh-NEHnoun

What ma'aneh means

an answer: the reply that comes back when someone speaks, asks, or accuses

TranslatabilityApproximateCertaintyStrong

This noun comes straight off the verb "to answer" (עָנָה), and it names the thing that comes back. It is not speech in general and not a message sent out; it is the return half of an exchange, the words that land after someone else has already spoken. That is why it turns up where two parties are facing each other: three friends arguing with Job, a person standing in front of someone else's temper, seers waiting on God for a word.

Because it is the return half, the word carries a quiet judgment about fit. A reply can be soft and drain the anger out of a quarrel, or it can arrive at the right moment and delight the person who gives it. When it is missing, the absence itself says something loud: Job's three friends found no answer, and Elihu's anger flares exactly there. In Micah the silence belongs to God, and it leaves the fortune tellers standing with their mouths covered.

Proverbs then pushes the word one step further. In Proverbs 16:1 the reply a person finally speaks is credited to the LORD, so even the words that feel most our own arrive as a gift. In Proverbs 16:4 the noun stretches past speech altogether: everything the LORD made has something it answers to, the end it was built to match. English Bibles usually render that "for its purpose", which is how a word for "answer" ends up meaning "aim". The same drift produced the small bound word behind "for the sake of" (מַעַן).

Nuances

1aa reply between people: what someone says back in conversation or in an argument
Job 32:3Job 32:5Pro 15:1Pro 15:23
1ban answer from God: the word he gives back to those who ask him, and the reply he puts on a person's tongue
Pro 16:1Mic 3:7
1cwhat something answers to: the matching end a thing was made for
TranslatabilityPartialCertaintyContested
Pro 16:4
Pro 16:4

In Proverbs 16:4, whether the pronoun attached to מַעֲנֶה refers to each created thing ("for its own purpose") or to YHWH ("for himself").

  • majorityThe suffix is objective and refers to each thing the LORD made: he made everything for the end that answers to it, and the wicked for the day of trouble is the illustration that follows in the second line.; BDB, s.v. מַעֲנֶה; HALOT, s.v. מַעֲנֶה; Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 10-31, Anchor Yale Bible 18B (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009)
  • minorityThe suffix refers to YHWH: the LORD made everything for his own sake. This is the reading carried by the Latin Vulgate (propter semetipsum, "for his own sake") and by the King James Version.; Vulgate, Proverbs 16:4 (universa propter semetipsum operatus est Dominus)

What scholars say about ma'aneh

מַעֲנֶה is a mem-preformative noun from עָנָה I, "to answer, respond," and the standard lexica (BDB, HALOT, DCH) treat it as a single lexeme, "answer, response," attested seven times and confined to Job, Proverbs, and Micah. The concentration in wisdom literature is not accidental: Fox and Waltke both read the Proverbs occurrences within the collection's sustained interest in speech that fits its moment, with 15:1 and 15:23 forming a pair on the effect and the timing of a reply, and 16:1 belonging to the Yahweh sayings that subordinate human speech to divine disposal. Clines takes Job 32:3 and 32:5 together as the narrative pivot into the Elihu speeches, where the friends' failure to produce a מַעֲנֶה licenses a new speaker. Micah 3:7 uses the construct phrase מַעֲנֵה אֱלֹהִים of the oracular response the diviners fail to obtain, a specialized use of the noun for a divine answer to inquiry. The contested occurrence is Proverbs 16:4, where לַמַּעֲנֵהוּ is glossed "for its purpose, for its own end" in the lexica, while the Vulgate (propter semetipsum, "for his own sake") and the King James tradition refer the suffix to YHWH. The semantic bridge from "response" to "purpose" visible in that verse is the same one behind the particle מַעַן (H4616), which BDB, following König, parses as an abbreviation of מַעֲנֶה.

Sources

  • BDB, s.v. מַעֲנֶהlexicon
  • HALOT, s.v. מַעֲנֶהlexicon
  • DCH, s.v. מַעֲנֶהlexicon
  • TDOT, s.v. עָנָהtheological-dictionary
  • Michael V. Fox, Proverbs 10-31, Anchor Yale Bible 18B (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009)commentary
  • Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 15-31, New International Commentary on the Old Testament (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2005)commentary
  • David J. A. Clines, Job 21-37, Word Biblical Commentary 18A (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2006)commentary
  • Delbert R. Hillers, Micah, Hermeneia (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1984)commentary

All attested forms of מַעֲנֶה

m s absolute

מַעֲנֶה

Job 32:3, Job 32:5, Pro 15:1

m s construct

מַעֲנֵה

Pro 15:23, Pro 16:1, Mic 3:7

m s construct

מַּעֲנֵהוּ

Pro 16:4