to carry something through or across a place, or to be carried along by an outside force
TranslatabilityApproximateCertaintySettled
This is the plain, physical sense: to pick something up and carry it from one place through or across another. The base verb φέρω simply means to carry or bear, and adding the idea of "through" gives this word its picture of movement across a space.
The same verb turns to the passive easily, and then it describes being carried along rather than doing the carrying. When the thing carried is a ship, it means being driven helplessly across open water. When the thing carried is a message, it means news being carried through a whole region until it has spread everywhere. In each case something is moved through a space, whether on its own errand, by a storm, or by word of mouth.
Nuances
1ato carry an object through or across a place
Mrk 11:16
1bto be driven along helplessly, as a ship in a storm
Act 27:27
1cto be carried throughout a region, of news spreading
Act 13:49
2
to differ from something else, to be unlike it
TranslatabilityDirectCertaintySettled
From the idea of carrying things apart in different directions comes the sense of things standing apart, being unlike each other. One star outshines another; an heir who is still a child looks no different in practice from a household servant.
Greek also used the word in a fixed turn of phrase meaning "it makes no difference" or "it does not matter to me." Paul speaks that way when he says the past standing of the Jerusalem leaders makes no difference to him. The thread holding these together is simple contrast: two things measured against each other and found unlike, or found to matter equally little.
Nuances
2ato be different from or unlike another thing
1Co 15:41Gal 4:1
2bimpersonal: it makes no difference, it does not matter
Gal 2:6
3
to be worth more than something else, to surpass it in value or importance
TranslatabilityApproximateCertaintyStrong
When two things differ and one comes out ahead, the word shifts from "differ" to "be worth more." This is its most frequent use in the New Testament, and almost always to reassure: if God feeds the birds, how much more will he care for you, who are worth far more than they are.
The same comparison reaches past worth to importance. In two of Paul's letters the phrase behind "the things that are excellent" can mean either the things that genuinely matter most or, on an older reading, simply the things that differ and so must be told apart. Both readings rest on the one idea at the word's core: some things rise above others.
Nuances
3ato be of more value than something else
Mat 6:26Mat 10:31Mat 12:12Luk 12:7Luk 12:24
3bthe things that surpass: what is superior or of greatest importance
Rom 2:18*Php 1:10*
Rom 2:18
Whether the participial phrase (to dokimazein ta diapheronta) means "approve the things that really matter" (diapherō in its "be worth more" sense) or "distinguish the things that differ" (diapherō in its "differ" sense), a call to moral discernment.
majorityApprove what is superior or really matters; the phrase names the things of higher worth that the believer is to value and endorse.; BDAG, s.v. διαφέρω; C.E.B. Cranfield, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans (ICC)
minorityDistinguish the things that differ; the phrase calls for testing things in order to tell them apart.; J.B. Lightfoot, Saint Paul's Epistle to the Philippians
Php 1:10
Whether the phrase (dokimazein ta diapheronta) means "approve the things that really matter" (diapherō as "be worth more") or "distinguish or test the things that differ" (diapherō as "differ").
majorityApprove what is superior or really matters; the believer's love is to grow in discerning the things of higher worth.; BDAG, s.v. διαφέρω; Gordon D. Fee, Paul's Letter to the Philippians (NICNT)
minorityDistinguish the things that differ; the phrase asks the believer to test things in order to tell them apart.; J.B. Lightfoot, Saint Paul's Epistle to the Philippians
carries the concrete idea of moving or spreading something through a space, an errand or a message traveling across a place, which "be superior" never meansMrk 11:16Act 13:49
means simply to be different from something, to stand apart without any ranking of higher or lower1Co 15:41Gal 4:1
Both
both can say that one thing is worth more than or excels another, comparing their valueMat 6:26Mat 12:12Php 2:3Php 3:8
names being set over others in rank or office, holding a position of authority above them, a sense of standing above that the other word does not carryRom 13:11Pe 2:13
φέρωφέρω is the plain "carry, bear"; διαφέρω adds "through, apart," giving both "carry through" and, by extension, "differ."
diapherō in the other biblical languages
יָקַרHebrew“be precious”יָקַר describes being precious or valued in itself, where διαφέρω in its main New Testament sense weighs one thing as worth more than another.
What scholars say about diapherō
The verb combines φέρω "to carry" with the preposition διά "through, apart," yielding a literal sense of carrying through or across a space (Mark 11:16) and, in the passive, of being borne along, whether a storm-driven ship (Acts 27:27) or a report spreading through a region (Acts 13:49). From "carry apart" develop the intransitive "to differ" (1 Corinthians 15:41;Galatians 4:1) and the impersonal διαφέρει "it makes a difference" (Galatians 2:6). The comparative "to be superior, be worth more" (Matthew 6:26; 10:31; 12:12; Luke 12:7, 24) is the dominant New Testament use, always in dominical assurances of God's greater care for people. BDAG and LSJ treat these as facets of a single verb; the participial phrase δοκιμάζειν τὰ διαφέροντα (Romans 2:18;Philippians 1:10) is disputed between "approve what really matters" and "distinguish the things that differ."
Sources
BDAG, s.v. διαφέρωlexicon
LSJ, s.v. διαφέρωlexicon
C.E.B. Cranfield, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans (ICC)commentary
Gordon D. Fee, Paul's Letter to the Philippians (NICNT)commentary
J.B. Lightfoot, Saint Paul's Epistle to the Philippianscommentary