barren: unable to bring forth young, so that no child is ever born
This word names one condition: no children have come, and, left as things are, none will. It is not the word for grief over a child who has died or been lost, which Hebrew handles separately (שַׁכּוּל), and it is not a general word for bleakness or desolation (גַּלְמוּד). It is the plain description of someone who has borne nothing.
It belongs to a family of words built around the idea of a root or a base. The same root gives a verb used for tearing a plant up by the roots and for crippling a captured warhorse by cutting the tendon at the base of its leg (עִקֵּר). Scholars disagree about how the picture travelled from roots to childlessness, but the family connection itself is not in doubt. One line in Deuteronomy also settles a common misunderstanding: the promise there covers a barren man as well as a barren woman, and the livestock too. So this is not by definition a word about women, even though every other place it appears it does describe a woman.
Almost everywhere it turns up, it is the setup for a reversal:
- three of the four great mothers in Genesis are introduced with this single word, and each of them eventually bears a son
- the covenant blessing in Exodus and Deuteronomy promises that no one in the land will be in this condition
- Hannah's song and Psalm 113 make the childless woman the picture of how God turns situations upside down
- Isaiah tells a ruined city, addressed as a childless woman, to break out singing because her children will outnumber the married woman's
The one exception is in Job, where a childless woman appears not as a story waiting to turn but as someone easy to prey on, a woman with no grown sons to stand up for her. That verse is the reminder that behind the reversals lies a real and dangerous social position.
Nuances
Whether the childless woman of Isaiah 54:1 is a deliberate identification of Zion with Sarah, or a broader use of the childless-woman figure fused with the image of the deserted city.
- contestedA specific Sarah typology: the prophet uses the very word applied to Sarah and has already named her three chapters earlier, so Zion is being cast as the new Sarah.; Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40-55 (Anchor Bible 19A, 2002), 359-363; Benjamin D. Sommer, A Prophet Reads Scripture: Allusion in Isaiah 40-66 (Stanford, 1998)
- contestedA wider reappropriation of the childless-woman tradition, in which the matriarchs are one strand among others and the desolate-city image remains distinguishable from the barren matriarch.; Mary Callaway, Sing, O Barren One: A Study in Comparative Midrash (SBLDS 91; Scholars Press, 1986), 59-88; Kamila Blessing, Desolate Jerusalem and Barren Matriarch, Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha 18 (1998): 47-69