to deceive: to lure someone into a false sense of security or hope so their own judgment is corrupted
This verb names a very particular kind of deception. It is not simply telling a lie (that is כזב), nor betraying someone who trusted you (that is רמה), nor coaxing a vulnerable person into something (that is פתה). It is the act of lulling a person or a whole nation into misplaced confidence: feeding them a false hope or a false sense of safety until they can no longer see their real danger.
The word turns up at some of the tensest moments in the Hebrew Bible. The serpent uses it to Eve in the garden. An Assyrian officer flings it at the crowd on the walls of Jerusalem, warning them not to let King Hezekiah, and then not to let God, fool them into holding out. Jeremiah uses it of the prophets who promised peace that never came. It is the language of propaganda and false assurance in a crisis.
The same core action shows up from several angles:
- one person or power deceiving another into false confidence
- people deceiving themselves, lulling their own hearts with a hope they want to be true
- an inner attitude, especially pride, that deceives its owner from the inside
- the state of having been fooled, described from the victim's side
Its most disturbing appearance is in Jeremiah 4:10, the one place where God is the one who deceives. That single verse has generated centuries of debate, gathered below.
Nuances
How to read God as the subject of the verb in Jeremiah 4:10: whether it claims God actively deceived the people through the prophets of peace, only permitted them to be deceived, or whether the accusation should be shifted onto the false prophets.
- majorityA straightforward accusation: God himself misled the people through the optimistic promises of peace, and the prophet says so plainly.; Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), 149-55; Carroll, Jeremiah (OTL); McKane, Jeremiah 1-25 (ICC)
- minorityGod permitted the deception rather than performing it, the verb read as allowing the people to be deceived.; Chisholm, "Does God Deceive?" Bibliotheca Sacra 155 (1998): 11-28; Waltke and O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, 27.5c
- minorityThe deceiving is reassigned to the false prophets, by emending the text or following the ancient Aramaic translation, sparing God the accusation.; Duhm, Das Buch Jeremia; Targum Jonathan (ad loc.)