enmity: a settled, openly recognized state of being enemies, a lasting hostile relationship rather than a passing feeling
This word names a relationship, not a mood. It does not describe a flash of anger or the private feeling of hating someone (Hebrew has other words for that). It describes the standing condition of being enemies: a hostility that is public, lasting, and recognized by others, the kind that has real consequences attached.
The word appears only five times, in three very different settings, yet it means the same thing in each.
- In the garden, God himself sets enmity between the serpent and the woman and their descendants.
- In Israel's law, a prior state of enmity between two people is what separates murder from an accidental killing.
- In the prophets, it names the deep, old hostility of neighboring nations toward Israel.
What ties these together is that this enmity is a status you are in, not a feeling you have. It can be declared, traced back through past events, or projected forward as a permanent condition. And wherever it appears, something follows from it: a serpent struck at, a killer handed over, a nation cut off. It is never a hostility that can simply be left alone.
Nuances
How to characterize the enmity that Numbers 35 makes the test for murder: as evidence of the killer's intent, or as a publicly known relationship of hostility between the parties.
- contestedIt functions like what later law calls malice aforethought: the settled hostility shows the killing was intended, so intent is the decisive criterion.; Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990); Moshe Greenberg, 'Some Postulates of Biblical Criminal Law' (1960)
- contestedIt names a publicly declared, prior relationship of being enemies, a social and legal status rather than an inner mental state; the killing is murder because that hostile relationship already stood between the parties.; Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21-36 (Anchor Bible, 2000); Klaus-Peter Adam, Hate and Enmity in Biblical Law (T&T Clark, 2022); Pamela Barmash, Homicide in the Biblical World (Cambridge, 2005)