an uproar: the loud, disorderly noise of a crowd that has lost its order
At its center this word is a sound: the confused racket a group of people makes once it stops behaving in an orderly way. Everything else follows from that. Because a crowd that has lost its composure is dangerous, the word slides easily into naming a riot, and in the New Testament that is usually what it names. But the noise does not have to be angry. It can be grief, which is why the same word covers the wailing at a house where a child has just died.
In the New Testament this noun always stays outside a person. It is the noise in the street, the courtyard, or the crowded house, never a feeling churning inside someone. That is where it parts company with its matching verb (θορυβέω), which can turn inward and describe a mind thrown into confusion. The noun keeps the noise where you can hear it.
In public life the word carried real weight, because keeping crowds quiet was a governing job:
- The chief priests time their arrest of Jesus to avoid an uproar among the festival crowds (Matthew 26:5; Mark 14:2).
- Pilate washes his hands once he sees the noise rising instead of dying down (Matthew 27:24).
- A Roman commander cannot get a straight account out of a mob because of the din (Acts 21:34).
- Paul, on trial, insists he was found in the temple with no crowd and no uproar (Acts 24:18).
That last one is not a plea for good manners. Roman officials could be held responsible for disorder they failed to put down, so a man accused of causing an uproar was being accused of something close to a crime. Paul's denial is legal language, and the word is the charge he is answering.
Nuances
Whether the word here denotes the formal, semi-professional wailing customary at a Jewish funeral, or a broader loud commotion whose funeral coloring comes from the surrounding words (the flute players and the loud wailers).
- contestedThe word is culturally loaded and marks the scripted lament of hired mourners, expected even at the poorest funeral.; J. Marcus, Mark 1-8, AB 27 (Doubleday, 2000), 366-68, 370-72; W. D. Davies and D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC; T&T Clark, 1988-97), 2:129, 132-34; R. A. Guelich, Mark 1-8:26, WBC 34A (Word, 1989), 302-3
- contestedThe word by itself asserts only noisy confusion; the funeral character is supplied by the context, not by the word.; R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC; Eerdmans, 2002), 239-40; A. Y. Collins, Mark: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Fortress, 2007), 285-86; M. D. Hooker, The Gospel according to Saint Mark, BNTC (A and C Black, 1991), 150