StrongerBible

dialogismos

διαλογισμός

GreekG1261thought, argument, ...

Appears 14 times · tap a cell to see the verses

Mat 15:19Mrk 7:21Luk 2:35Luk 5:22Luk 6:8Luk 9:46Luk 9:47Luk 24:38Rom 1:21Rom 14:11Co 3:20Php 2:141Ti 2:8Jas 2:4
Root family
Word studydee-ah-lo-gis-MOSSnoun

What dialogismos means

1

an inner reasoning of the heart: the thoughts, deliberations, and designs a person turns over privately, often futile or corrupt

TranslatabilityApproximateCertaintyStrong

At its root this word names the mind at work: turning something over, weighing it, reasoning it through. In the New Testament that inner activity is almost always shown in a bad light. The reasonings are called evil, futile, or dark, and they are the hidden contents of the heart that God alone perceives and brings to light.

The range within this one meaning runs from settled opinions a person holds, to the anxious doubts that rise up unbidden, to the corrupt schemes that spill out into sin. What holds them together is that they are all the private traffic of the heart. Luke in particular uses the word for the reasonings Jesus reads in people before they say a word.

The closest Hebrew counterpart is מַחֲשָׁבָה, the word for a thought, plan, or scheme; Paul quotes it with this Greek word when he says the Lord knows that the reasonings of the wise are futile. Among Greek words it sits near λογισμός, plain calculation or argument, but adds the sense of back-and-forth deliberating and its typically negative coloring.

Nuances

1athe hidden reasonings of the heart that God perceives and exposes
Luk 2:35Luk 5:22Luk 6:8Luk 9:47Rom 1:211Co 3:20
1bevil thoughts, corrupt designs that issue in wrongdoing
Mat 15:19Mrk 7:21Jas 2:4
1cdoubt, the anxious questionings that rise up in the heart
TranslatabilityDirect
Luk 24:38
1dan opinion or personal scruple a believer holds
Rom 14:1
2

a dispute: the quarreling and complaining that breaks out when people press competing views

TranslatabilityApproximateCertaintyStrong

When the reasoning is not kept inside one person but breaks out between people, the same word names the quarrel that results. It is the disputing that arises when each presses his own view, the wrangling and complaining that can poison a community.

Paul twice sets it beside grumbling and anger: believers are to do everything without grumbling and disputing, and to pray without anger and quarreling. The word here is not calm debate but the peevish contention that fractures fellowship. It stands close to γογγυσμός, muttered complaint, and shades toward open argument.

Luk 9:46Php 2:141Ti 2:8

What scholars say about dialogismos

The noun derives from the verb dialogizomai, to reason or deliberate, and denotes the process or product of reasoning. In the Septuagint it commonly renders forms of the Hebrew machashabah/chashab word group (thought, plan, scheme), and the negative sense of Psalm 94:11 carries directly into Paul's citation at 1 Corinthians 3:20. BDAG groups the New Testament usage under the reasoning/thought/opinion range and a distinct verbal exchange sense (dispute, argument), citing Luke 9:46, Philippians 2:14, and 1 Timothy 2:8 for the latter. Schrenk (TDNT 2:95-97) stresses that the word almost always bears an unfavorable nuance in the New Testament, denoting the corrupt or hostile reasoning of the human heart that stands under divine scrutiny. EDNT (Balz and Schneider) notes the same negative coloring and treats the range from inner deliberation to open dispute as contextually determined. The rendering of 1 Timothy 2:8 is contested between dissension/quarreling (favored by the pairing with orge, anger) and doubting; commentators on the Pastoral Epistles discuss both.

Sources

  • BDAG, s.v. διαλογισμόςlexicon
  • G. Schrenk, TDNT 2:95-97, s.v. διαλογισμός / διαλογίζομαιtheological-dictionary
  • EDNT 1:308, s.v. διαλογισμόςtheological-dictionary

All attested forms of διαλογισμός

nominative m p

διαλογισμοὶ, διαλογισμοί

Mat 15:19, Mrk 7:21, Luk 24:38, Luk 2:35

accusative m p

διαλογισμοὺς

Luk 5:22, Luk 6:8, 1Co 3:20

genitive m p

διαλογισμῶν

Rom 14:1, Php 2:14, Jas 2:4

accusative m s

διαλογισμὸν

Luk 9:47

dative m p

διαλογισμοῖς

Rom 1:21

genitive m s

διαλογισμοῦ

1Ti 2:8

nominative m s

διαλογισμὸς

Luk 9:46