the grinding or gnashing of teeth: the noisy clenching of the teeth together, used in the New Testament only in the set phrase "weeping and gnashing of teeth" for the reaction of those shut out of God's kingdom
The word names a noisy action of the teeth: their grinding or gnashing together. In wider Greek it could describe a bite, the chattering of teeth in a fever chill, or even a lion's growl, but the New Testament keeps it to one setting. It appears seven times, six in Matthew and once in Luke, and always inside the same fixed phrase, "there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth." It is paired every time with weeping (κλαυθμός), the sob of the same doomed people.
By itself the word says nothing about feeling. It names a sound the mouth makes, not the emotion behind it, so what the gnashing means has to be read from the scene. Each time it falls on people who have been shut out: thrown into the darkness outside a lit banquet hall, or into the fire, while others are welcomed in.
Two older streams feed the picture, and they pull in different directions. In the Old Testament, gnashing the teeth (the Hebrew verb חָרַק) is nearly always aggression aimed at someone else: the enemy who grinds his teeth at the godly in scorn or threat. The one clear New Testament use of the matching Greek verb (βρύχω), a mob gnashing at Stephen as they stone him, is plainly rage. Later Jewish writing about the world to come, though, uses the same image for the anguish of the condemned themselves. The Gospel phrase stands between the two, and scholars still divide over whether it voices fury, despair, or both at once.
Disputed
What the gnashing of teeth expresses in the New Testament judgment scenes: despairing remorse, hostile rage, or a fixed idiom that fuses both.
- majorityIt denotes despairing remorse and self-reproach, the anguish of those who realize too late that they are shut out; joined to weeping, the older sense of anger yields to anguished suffering. This is the dominant lexicographical judgment.; Karl Heinrich Rengstorf, "βρύχω, βρυγμός," Theological Dictionary of the New Testament (TDNT) I:641–642; Donald A. Hagner, Matthew 1–13 (WBC 33A), 206; J. P. Louw and E. A. Nida, Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament Based on Semantic Domains, domain 23.40
- minorityIt is an aggressive expression of hostility and anger, in line with the Psalter and Lamentations, where gnashing is fury aimed at the righteous, and with Acts 7:54, the only undisputed New Testament use of the verb.; John Nolland, The Gospel of Matthew (NIGTC), 358
- minorityIt is a fixed apocalyptic formula whose emotional content is composite, fusing impotent fury with anguished regret; being idiomatic, it resists being reduced to a single emotion, and the setting of belated exclusion calls for both.; Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (AB 28A), 1026; W. D. Davies and D. C. Allison Jr., The Gospel According to Saint Matthew (ICC), II:27–32; I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC), 568