to go down well with someone: to be sweet, welcome, or acceptable to the person on the receiving end
This verb always looks at things from the receiving end. It does not say that something is sweet in itself; it says that something went down well with a particular person, and Hebrew nearly always names that person: sweet to me, pleasing to him, welcome to the LORD. Take the person away and the verb has nothing left to say.
The handful of subjects it takes hang together:
- sleep that comes easily and leaves a person rested
- a longing that has finally been satisfied
- an offering or a prayer brought to God
- a woman who was agreeable to the men around her
None of these is an achievement. Each is something handed over to somebody who then either welcomes it or does not.
Most of its appearances are about worship, and there the verb carries real weight. Jeremiah has God turn away imported incense and sacrifices as unwelcome. Hosea says the bread of mourners will not be welcome to him. Malachi promises a day when the offering of Judah and Jerusalem will be welcome again as it once was. Psalm 104 aims the same verb at a person's own words, asking that the singer's musing be welcome to God, which quietly puts a song where a sacrifice normally stands.
Hebrew has other ways of saying sweet and pleasant, and they do different jobs. The adjective built from the same root (עָרֵב) calls the thing itself sweet, whether it is food or a voice. The verb for tasting sweet (מָתֹק) stays in the mouth. The regular worship word for God receiving someone with favor (רָצָה) puts God in the active position, where this verb keeps the spotlight on the gift and on how it landed.
Nuances
Whether Hosea 9:4 originally read this verb at all. The consonants of the received text differ by a single letter from a common verb meaning to set out or arrange, and the verse's imagery of pouring out wine and setting food before God has led some critics to prefer that other verb.
- majorityKeep the received text: their sacrifices will not be pleasing to the LORD. The standard lexica assume this reading when they list the verse among the attestations of the stative verb, and the close parallel at Jeremiah 6:20, where sacrifices are likewise not pleasing to God, supports it.; HALOT, s.v. ערב; DCH, s.v. ערב
- minorityEmend to the verb meaning to arrange or set out, so that the line reads that they shall not set out their sacrifices before the LORD. This proposal belongs to the older critical tradition and is recorded in the lexicographic literature.; BDB, s.v. עָרַב III, recording the proposal of Kuenen, Cheyne, Wellhausen, G. A. Smith, and Nowack