to be guilty: to become answerable for wrongdoing, and so to bear its penalty
This verb holds together two ideas English usually keeps apart: doing wrong and paying for it. To be guilty here is not just a feeling or a verdict in someone's mind; it is a real change in a person's standing that carries real consequences. The same word covers the moment a person crosses a line and the ruin that later falls on them for it.
One strand names the offense itself, the point at which someone incurs guilt. This is where the priestly laws use it again and again, in the steady refrain that a person who breaks a command is guilty and must make it right. The focus is on the fact of the wrong, not the punishment yet to come.
The other strand names the outcome: guilty people, and even their land and animals, are held to account and suffer for it. The prophets use the word this way when a nation is laid waste or a wrongdoer is destroyed. A rarer use turns the word outward, asking God to treat someone as guilty, that is, to condemn them.
Because the wrong and its penalty are wrapped into one word, translators have to choose which side to bring out in each verse, and often no single English word can carry both at once.
Nuances
Disputed
In the priestly laws of Leviticus, whether the verb means to incur guilt objectively, a change in standing before God, or to feel and realize one's guilt subjectively, the inner recognition that then leads to confession and the reparation offering.
- minorityThe priestly usage is subjective: the person comes to feel or realize guilt, and this is the trigger for confession and the guilt-offering.; Jacob Milgrom, Cult and Conscience: The Asham and the Priestly Doctrine of Repentance (Leiden: Brill, 1976); Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1-16 (Anchor Bible; New York: Doubleday, 1991)
- majorityThe verb keeps its objective force: the person becomes guilty and so is liable, with the consequential nuance of suffering for that guilt seen elsewhere in the prophets.; BDB, s.v. אשׁם; K. Koch, "אָשָׁם / אשׁם," TDOT 1:429-437