an Eastern sage: a learned man from Persia or Babylon who read the stars, interpreted dreams, and advised kings
This is the honored side of the word. It names the wise men of the East, a professional class of star-readers, dream-interpreters, and royal counselors whose learning went back to the priestly and court traditions of Persia and Babylon. The Greek Old Testament reserved this word for exactly that setting: in the book of Daniel it labels the Babylonian court experts (אַשָּׁף), and Daniel himself is even set over them.
Matthew reaches for this dignified sense when he brings the wise men from the East to worship the newborn king. Their star-watching marks them as astrologers, and their long journey and homage cast them as impressive foreign sages who recognize a king when Israel's own leaders do not. The tone is respectful, even admiring, though the word never fully sheds the whiff of the occult that clung to it in ordinary Greek.
English has no clean equivalent. Some translations say "wise men," some say "astrologers," and many simply carry the Greek word over as "Magi," which is really an admission that no single English word will do.
Disputed
How Matthew presents the magi: as admirable Gentile sages, as ignorant outsiders, or as figures of deliberately uncertain background.
- majorityThey are admirable Gentile astrologers whose homage to the newborn king foreshadows the welcome of the nations, echoing the Balaam oracle of Numbers 22-24.; R. E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah (rev. ed. 1993); W. D. Davies and D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 1 (1988)
- minorityTheir strength is their ignorance: they know a star but not the scriptures, so revelation comes to the unlearned as Matthew 11:25 describes.; M. A. Powell, 'The Magi as Wise Men,' NTS 46 (2000) 1-20
- minorityMatthew leaves their ethnicity open and may even envision them as Jewish.; D. C. Sim, 'The Magi: Gentiles or Jews?' HTS 55 (1999) 980-1000