the charge itself: a formal accusation stated against a named person, of the kind that has to be answered before a judge or a governing body
This is a courtroom word. It was built from a verb meaning to speak against someone in the public square, which was where trials and public business were held, and it names one precise thing: the complaint as actually lodged. Not the person who brings it (κατήγορος), not the act of accusing (κατηγορέω), and not the wrongdoing that supposedly happened (αἰτία), but the stated charge the accused now has to answer. Everyday legal paperwork from the same centuries uses it exactly this way, for the accusation in a real lawsuit.
All three uses in the New Testament sit in settings where a charge has to be put into words and then tested:
- Pilate opens the hearing by demanding to know the charge, because a Roman trial could not proceed without one.
- Paul tells Timothy not even to take up a charge against an elder unless two or three witnesses stand behind it.
- Titus is told that an elder's children should be clear of any charge of wild living that could actually be made to stick.
The formality is part of the word. Ancient writers on Greek vocabulary drew a sharp line between this kind of open, stated, answerable charge and the quiet damaging rumor, which had a separate word of its own and gave us the title "slanderer" for the devil. That line matters for reading the passages about elders: the concern in both letters is not with hurt feelings or unkind talk but with a specific allegation that someone is prepared to press, and with whether it can be supported.
The answer to a charge had its own name, a spoken defense (ἀπολογία), and the two words were a standing pair in Greek: prosecution and defense, the two halves of a trial. That pairing runs deep in the Bible's picture of God's court, where an accuser presses charges against God's people and an advocate speaks for them.