visitation: the moment God comes near to attend to his people, whether to rescue or to hold them to account
At its root this word pictures someone in a higher position looking down to inspect and attend to someone below. When that someone is God, the word names a decisive moment: God draws near, sees the true state of his people, and acts on what he finds. The same word covers a coming in blessing and a coming in judgment, because which one it turns out to be depends entirely on whether the people are found faithful or guilty.
This double edge is not a flaw in the word. It comes straight out of the Hebrew scriptures, where the prophets spoke of a day when God would come to reckon with his people, and where God also came to rescue and preserve them. The Greek word carried both possibilities at once.
In the two places the New Testament uses it this way, one is settled and one is disputed. When Jesus wept over Jerusalem and said the city did not recognize the time of its visitation, he meant God's gracious coming in his own ministry, an offer of rescue that was refused and so turned into judgment. When Peter told his readers that outsiders watching their good lives would glorify God on the day of visitation, scholars still disagree over whether he meant:
- a final day of judgment
- the moment those outsiders are drawn to faith
- a day left deliberately open to both.
Whether the day of visitation in 1 Peter 2:12 refers to final judgment, to the conversion of the outsiders who observe Christian conduct, or to an intentionally ambivalent day that brings both.
- contestedThe final eschatological judgment. The Septuagint temporal-noun idiom for a day of visitation is overwhelmingly judicial, and the glorifying of God is either the vindication of the righteous or an acknowledgment forced from opponents at the last day.; Paul J. Achtemeier, 1 Peter, Hermeneia; John H. Elliott, 1 Peter, Anchor Yale Bible
- contestedThe conversion of the outsiders. Having observed Christian conduct, they are drawn to faith and glorify God when he visits them in grace, comparable to Matthew 5:16.; J. Ramsey Michaels, 1 Peter, Word Biblical Commentary; Peter H. Davids, The First Epistle of Peter, NICNT; Karen H. Jobes, 1 Peter, BECNT
- contestedA deliberately ambivalent day: grace for those brought to faith through Christian witness, judgment for the impenitent.; Leonhard Goppelt, A Commentary on 1 Peter; Joel B. Green, 1 Peter, THNTC