to carry in: to bring a person or thing from outside to inside, or to put someone into a situation
This is a plain, workaday Greek verb built out of two ordinary parts: the common verb for carrying or bearing, φέρω, with a prefix meaning "into." It means what its parts say. Four friends try to get a paralyzed man through a crowded doorway with this word; a priest takes the blood of a sacrifice into the holy place with it. Nothing about the word is religious or technical in itself. Outside the Bible it was the everyday verb of taxpayers, shippers, brides bringing a dowry, and clerks filing documents.
From that simple base the New Testament stretches the word in a few natural directions, much as English stretches "bring in":
- officials bring a person in by force, hauling them before a council to answer for themselves
- a traveling teacher brings a strange new idea in, setting it before people who have never heard it
- a human being is brought into the world at birth, the world pictured as a room one arrives in empty-handed
- God is asked not to bring his people into a season of testing
What holds all of this together is that someone else is always doing the carrying. That sets the word apart from εἰσέρχομαι, which is what a person does when they walk in under their own steam, and gives it a heavier feel than the neighboring verb "to lead in" (εἰσάγω): you can be carried somewhere you never chose to go. Its exact opposite, "to carry out" (ἐκφέρω), is set against it in one memorable line: we carried nothing in at birth, and we can carry nothing out at death.
One clause of the Lord's Prayer accounts for nearly all the argument over this word: "do not bring us into testing." The Greek itself is not hard to read, and it plainly makes God the one who does the bringing, which is exactly why the line unsettles readers and why some churches have reworded it to "do not let us enter." The difficulty lies not in this verb but in the questions standing behind it: what kind of testing is meant, and how God's rule over hard seasons relates to the evil he never authors.
Nuances
Whether the verb in the Lord's Prayer petition asks God not to bring his people into testing, or carries a permissive shade from a Semitic original, "do not let us enter into testing."
- majorityThe Greek is causative and God is its agent: the petition asks God not to bring his people into testing. In the Greek Old Testament this verb regularly renders the Hebrew causative of the verb "to come, go," and a translator who wanted a permissive sense had ordinary ways to say so and did not use them.; Joseph A. Fitzmyer, "And Lead Us Not into Temptation," Biblica 84 (2003): 259-273; Ulrich Luz, Matthew 1-7 (Hermeneia); W. D. Davies and Dale C. Allison, The Gospel According to Saint Matthew, vol. 1 (ICC); François Bovon, Luke 2: A Commentary on the Gospel of Luke 9:51-19:27 (Hermeneia); R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
- minorityAn Aramaic or Hebrew original lies behind the Greek in which the causative form with a negative could carry permissive force, so the petition originally meant "do not let us enter into testing" or "do not let us succumb." A Jewish evening prayer preserved in the Talmud uses the corresponding Hebrew wording in just this way.; Joachim Jeremias, The Prayers of Jesus (SBT 2/6); Jean Carmignac, Recherches sur le "Notre Père"; I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
Whether the verb in the Lord's Prayer petition asks God not to bring his people into testing, or carries a permissive shade from a Semitic original, "do not let us enter into testing."
- majorityThe Greek is causative and God is its agent: the petition asks God not to bring his people into testing. In the Greek Old Testament this verb regularly renders the Hebrew causative of the verb "to come, go," and a translator who wanted a permissive sense had ordinary ways to say so and did not use them.; Joseph A. Fitzmyer, "And Lead Us Not into Temptation," Biblica 84 (2003): 259-273; François Bovon, Luke 2: A Commentary on the Gospel of Luke 9:51-19:27 (Hermeneia); Ulrich Luz, Matthew 1-7 (Hermeneia)
- minorityAn Aramaic or Hebrew original lies behind the Greek in which the causative form with a negative could carry permissive force, so the petition originally meant "do not let us enter into testing" or "do not let us succumb."; Joachim Jeremias, The Prayers of Jesus (SBT 2/6); I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC); Jean Carmignac, Recherches sur le "Notre Père"